Source Monitoring in Child Forensic Interviews

Serving all of West Michigan including Ottawa, Muskegon, Allegan, Kent, and Van Buren County

Call (616) 931-7030 for a Free Criminal Defense Consultation

Ofrecemos interprete calificado en el sistema judicial, para servir a nuestros clientes.

Source Monitoring in Child Forensic Interviews

Source Monitoring – A Crucial Aspect of Forensic Interviewing As It Relates To Children

Weise Law is a boutique criminal defense firm practicing in all of West Michigan. We have case experience in all criminal cases, with an emphasis on criminal sexual conduct charges. Perhaps the most important aspect of these types of cases is the forensic interview of the accuser by law enforcement. A crucial aspect of the forensic interview often is source monitoring as it relates to child forensic interviews. To learn more about this topic please check out our recent blog on our website, www.weisecriminaldefense.com

How Do We Know What We Know?

The set of processes attributed to the origins of memories, knowledge, and beliefs is knowns as “source monitoring”. The question, “How do we know,  what we know?” is answered through source monitoring.

According to researchers, a study of preschool-aged children, where most children reported seeing an event, that they only heard about from another child, demonstrated that children’s interactions with one another was a significant influence on the false reports among children who only heard about the event, and had not witnessed or experienced the event themselves. In this given study children in group (a) participated in and witnessed an event, while children in group (b) did not witness  the event but heard about it from children in group (a). The number of children in group (b) that reported seeing this even was nearly the same as the children in group (a) who had experienced it.

Four Identified Reasons For Reporting, But Not Experiencing Events

There are four identified reasons that young children are vulnerable to repeating what they overhear but do not actually experience, when telling about events. First, younger children struggle to keep track of the source of their memories, this puts them at an increased risk for believing that events relayed to them by others are their own actual experiences. Second, children may be dependent on others to figure out how to represent and retell their experiences. Third, younger children do not understand that others may have memories that are false, rather they believe that the mind literally copies an experience and therefore everything is true. Lastly,  children do not experience what a false memory feels like.

Studies such as these clearly show the difference in “knowing about an event and having a “memory” of that event. At times children may know of an event and then talk as if they remember it. Children who are accurately reporting their own experiences can provide relevant details about their experiences. While, children who know of an event or have been given false information may also report experiencing the event, with rich details that make the narrative sound more believable.

References

Dr. Dan Swerdlow-Freed (2018) What is Source Monitoring and Why is it Relevant to Forensic Interviews of Children?

To learn even more about how the experienced defense lawyers at Weise Law can use this information to directly impact your case, call us at (616) 931-7030.

Here's a few of our valued client's reviews of our criminal defense work:

five star reviews personal injury lawyer
Outstanding lawyer. Cannot say enough about this mans compassion,knowledge an work ethics, he returns calls, keeps you informed thru the process an goes above an beyond the norm.. He is an awesome lawyer that cares an has been an asset to my son an I during this process. Highly recommended !
Posted by Gary August 20, 2016
August 20, 2016
five star reviews personal injury lawyer
Weise Law did everything in it's power under the law, to protect, defend, and represent me in a time of need. While dreary, and surreal, a pending criminal case, they seemed the only positive factor, and for that, they should be held in high regard and highly sought, perhaps more then just as a defense team. Thank you, Weise Law!
Neil H.
a year ago
five star reviews personal injury lawyer
Best Attorney Out There! Bill is a wonderful, intelligent and well spoken attorney. Through the process of his representation he not only was my lawyer, but became a friend. Bill is efficient and highly respected. I trusted Bill with my life and he did not disappoint! Highly, highly recommend him for any legal needs!
Posted by anonymous November 11, 2016
November 11, 2016

We can defend you in all types of criminal charges including felony, misdemeanor, and juvenile cases throughout West Michigan.

Our Criminal Defense Team has Over 30 Years Combined Experience in the Criminal Justice System. We are available 24/7 by phone. Call us if you need immediate help.